Security Council Open Debate on Threats to International Peace and Security, May 2016

Wednesday, May 11, 2016

Open Debate: Threat to international Peace and Security Caused by Terroristic Acts.

 

11 May, 2016

 

Overview

On Wednesday May 11, 2016, under the Egyptian presidency, the Security Council held an open debate under the theme, "Countering the narratives and ideologies of terrorism: Threats to International Peace and Security caused by terrorist acts." Inspired by the ideas of the concept note S/2016/416 circulated by Egypt prior the debate, speakers highlighted the importance of countering the narratives and ideologies of terrorist groups which are inspiring people from across the globe to leave their homes and join terrorists’ ranks. They also discussed how terrorist groups use their narratives and ideologies—based on distorted interpretations of religion—to justify their acts of violence, to recruit supporters and fighters, to mobilise resources, and to target global audiences through propaganda in social media. The outcome of this debate was the request to the United Nations Counter-Terrorism Committee contained in a presidential statement issued by the 15-member Council. This request called, specifically, for the Committee to recommend guidelines and good practices to that end by 30 April 2017. The Council expressed its concerns about the distorted narratives that Islamic State in Iraq and the Levant (ISIL/Da’esh), Al-Qaida and associated individuals, groups, undertakings and entities crafted based on misinterpretation and misrepresentation of religion to justify violence. It proposed that the international community should consider a number of concrete actions, such as developing a counter-narrative campaign to encourage and amplify those actively denouncing terrorism. Other proposed actions included developing the most effective means to counter terrorist propaganda, incitement and recruitment, including through the Internet, and raising public awareness of counter-terrorist narratives, including through education.

 

General Analysis

Different perspectives on countering violent extremism and its narratives have been discussed by Member States at the Open Debate on Wednesday.  Even though all States agree on the magnitude of the problem and the need to address it, tensions were demonstrated among members regarding how to strike a balance between preventing violent extremism and respecting state sovereignty, and between developing counter-terrorism strategies and upholding human rights. The speech of the representative of the United States concentrated on the fact that the counter-terrorism strategies must embrace legal action without infringing upon freedom of expression. Such a strategy, according to the speaker, should focus on exposing the lies that underpinned terrorist narratives through joint efforts alongside religious and civil society organizations, with Governments playing a supporting role by providing training. The representative of Saudi Arabia, on the other hand, insisted that the international community must adopt a comprehensive plan that would end terrorism and preserve the sovereignty, security and stability of all States. The overwhelming majority of speakers discussed that the young population of the world is most likely to become radicalized through terrorists’ social media recruitment techniques. Additionally, young people were identified as active players in countering violent extremism. As it has been pointed out by the Deputy Secretary-General, the investment of material resources in youth and their meaningful political empowerment is crucial. “Instead of viewing young people as part of the problem, we must harness their immense potential to forge solutions,” he stressed. In the same vein, speakers proposed  to shut down the cyberspace front lines of terrorist recruitment and incitement. The representative of the United Kingdom, in this vein, emphasized the need to work with technology companies, such as Microsoft, on addressing this issue. The new counter-terrorism strategy, according to the speakers, should include persuasive context-specific counter-narratives and messages to neutralize the influence of terrorists. According to the representative of South Africa, there is an urgent need to understand and address the conditions and contexts that made terrorism an attractive option. While the General Assembly is working on developing a future counter-terrorism convention and while the Global Counter-Terrorism Strategy review is approaching, a successful comprehensive international strategy for countering the narratives and ideologies of terrorist groups and the mechanism to coordinate, follow-up and mobilise the necessary action and resources are required. In this vein, the representative of the United Arab Emirates suggested that the Security Council should apply a single standard to all actors.

Gender Analysis

Out of nearly 58 statements delivered, only ten speakers (17.24%) used a specific gendered language. In his introductory remarks, the Deputy Secretary General underlined the need to listen carefully to affected communities and to engage them at the grass-roots level, where community and faith leaders, women and young people were on the front lines, standing up to violent extremists. Generally, the issue of women’s participation in peace processes and counter-terrorism measures has been highlighted by five speakers (8.6%) while the need to establish inclusive governance and inclusive dialogue has been emphasized by twenty-three speakers (39.6%). According to the representative of Bangladesh, it is critical to explore the potential role of women — traditionally seen as victims of terrorism — as agents of prevention, resilience and change. Overall, the issue of prevention has been covered by forty-nine speakers (84.5%). However, the role of women in preventative strategies have been covered only by few speakers in a variety of contexts. Women have been described as victims of the conflict by four speakers (6.7%). The representative of Afghanistan reminded everyone about the harsh realities of terror the world is witnessing today, including stoning women to death, closing girls’ schools and introducing suicide attacks that had brutalized Afghanistan’s entire population. The threat caused by terrorists’ access not only to cyberspace but also to deadly weapons has been covered by six speakers (10.3%). In this vein, the representative of Georgia suggested that in order effectively to prevent terrorists from acquiring them, the international community must enhance the existing security architecture and reinforce the physical security of sensitive materials. Frequently, Member States referred to issues related to the implementation of Security Council Resolutions  and other counterterrorism frameworks (24.13%), protection (32.7%) human rights (46.6%), and the rule of law (22.4%). However, States generally refrained from using gender-specific language.

Resources: 

Concept paper for the open debate of the Security Council on the theme “Threat to international Peace and Security Caused by Terroristic Acts”, 11 March 2016

Statement by the President of the Security Council on threats to international peace and security caused by terrorist acts, May 2016

Meeting Records: Threats to International Peace and Security caused by Terrorist Acts, May 11, 2016

Please choose

General Women, Peace and Security
  • Speaker

    Secretary-General of the United Nations
  • Extracts

    The Security Council recognized the value and role of young people and young peacebuilders in its historic resolution 2250 (2015) of December last year. That resolution will, I am sure, turn out to be the equivalent for young people of what resolution 1325 (2000) is for women and security.

  • Speaker

    Secretary-General of the United Nations
  • Extracts

    We also need to listen carefully to affected communities. We need to engage at the grass-roots level. We need to partner with faith leaders, women and young people. 

  • Country

    Malaysia
  • Extracts

    Long before the Geneva Conventions existed, Prophet Muhammad and subsequent scholars instituted a just-war doctrine. Among other things, during the conduct of war, Muslims are forbidden from harming non-combatants, particularly women, children, the elderly and the sick, as well as envoys, diplomats and those praying in houses of worship. They are even prohibited from harming civilian objects, including water wells, trees, crops and livestock. 

  • Country

    Malaysia
  • Extracts

    On a final note, I wish to stress that terrorist attacks do not discriminate among women or children; they do not discriminate between old or young; black or white; Muslims, Jews or Christians; rich or poor. All of us are potential victims of terrorism. In our response to this threat, let us not allow the terrorists to divide us. Hysterical responses to terrorism, including by discriminating against a group of people for their peaceful religious beliefs or branding an entire group of people as terrorists, will merely perpetuate terror and paranoia and further serve the terrorists’ narrative.

  • Country

    Spain
  • Extracts

    As occurred on Sunday with Cairo, Today we woke up to the news of new attacks in Baghdad, which have caused more than 70 fatalities. Most of the victims were women who were going to do their daily shopping. Once again, the daily lives of citizens have been tragically cut short. I offer my most heartfelt condolences to the people and the authorities of Iraq, and its Ambassador here present.

  • Country

    Spain
  • Extracts

    We know that in society itself — in civil society — there are moral forces and authoritative voices that rise against terrorism and violent extremism, and we must identify those voices. Besides having leaders and credible and authoritative voices, it is important to integrate the groups and communities that undertstand the problems and wish to contribute their proposals: young people, women, students and civil society organizations. Governments should not only consult each other, but also provide to social agents that promote peace and understanding with the support and platforms they need.

  • Country

    Ukraine
  • Extracts

    Only by combining more nuanced and comprehensive countering and prevention measures that address governance deficit, promote social development and dialogue and respect for the rule of law and human rights, develop strategic communications, engage women and youth and expand public-private partnerships can we reduce the appeal of and support for terrorist groups and enhance resilience against them. 

  • Country

    Netherlands
  • Extracts

    The dozens of ordinary men, women and children in a park in Lahore killed by a suicide bomber targeting Christians at Easter; the dozens of lives lost in terrorist strikes at Brussels’ airport and metro, and today, the tragic attacks in Baghdad killing at least 85 people underline the urgency of this debate.

  • Country

    Vatican
  • Extracts

    The theme of this open debate is extremely important, because it calls us to strike terrorism at its very roots and where it must primarily be fought, namely, in the hearts and minds of men and women, in particular of those who are most at risk of radicalization and recruitment by terrorist groups. 

  • Country

    Colombia
  • Extracts

    Women should be included in all stages of the design, implementation, monitoring and evaluation of counter-terrorism efforts. Those efforts must be accompanied by the promotion of education for girls and women, which in the medium- and long-term, enables them to increase their capabilities, knowledge and resources and which, by extension, will enable them to play a more active role in the actions that States and societies take in countering terrorism and violent extremism.

  • Country

    Indonesia
  • Extracts

    The role of family and women is important in educating individuals and assimilating them into the communities.

  • Country

    Indonesia
  • Extracts

    Secondly, deradicalization programmes must be complemented by counter-radicalization, which aims at providing the public with narratives to counter those of the terrorists. Our counter-radicalization programmes involve many important stakeholders, such as educational and religious institutions, youth organizations, media, women, victims of terrorist attacks and even former terrorists, at both the national and provincial levels. Within the context of counterradicalization, we have put in place appropriate measures to prevent the spread of terrorists’ messages through the Internet. We also use the Internet to prevent, detect and deter acts of terrorism. That include creating websites to disseminate messages of peace and respect and the gathering of information that may lead to the prevention of terrorism and prosecution of terrorist suspects.

  • Country

    Norway
  • Extracts

    Governments have the primary responsibility for preventing extremism, but they can only succeed if  they work closely with civil society, including with young people and women. That is why Norway has initiated the launch of two civil-society networks. First, there is YouthCAN, which is a network of young people working together against violent extremism, not least by developing alternative narratives. Secondly, we have established an alliance of women’s organizations. Many of the women in the alliance have suffered directly from extremism in places like Syria and Iraq. There can be no more qualified and credible voices in speaking out against terrorism than its victims and witnesses. Norway will continue to work with these networks and help them expand.

  • Country

    Bangladesh
  • Extracts

    Fourthly, it will be crucial to give due consideration to the impact of terrorist and violent extremist ideologies on women in affected communities. We must revisit the traditional approaches, in which women are seen as victims of terrorism and violent extremism, and further explore their potential roles as agents of prevention, resilience and change at the community level — and even as perpetrators.

  • Country

    Afghanistan
  • Extracts

    In the current global climate of unspeakable brutality committed by these terrorist outfits, let us not forget that it was the Taliban who stoned women to death; it was the Taliban who closed girls’ schools, thereby denying millions of girls of their right to education; it was the Taliban who prevented women from pursuing a livelihood; and it was they who introduced suicide attacks on civilians and destroyed towns and villages in Afghanistan. One can easily trace how the Taliban long started promoting Al-Qaida and Da’esh-style divisive and hateful ideology.

  • Country

    Palestine
  • Extracts

     Moreover, it is imperative to undertake efforts to foster an honest, open intercivilization and interreligious dialogue that involves and reaches not only leaders and Governments, but also the average civilian, including young people and women.

Participation
  • Speaker

    Secretary-General of the United Nations
  • Extracts

    We also need to listen carefully to affected communities. We need to engage at the grass-roots level. We need to partner with faith leaders, women and young people. 

  • Country

    Spain
  • Extracts

    As occurred on Sunday with Cairo, Today we woke up to the news of new attacks in Baghdad, which have caused more than 70 fatalities. Most of the victims were women who were going to do their daily shopping. Once again, the daily lives of citizens have been tragically cut short. I offer my most heartfelt condolences to the people and the authorities of Iraq, and its Ambassador here present.

  • Country

    Spain
  • Extracts

    We know that in society itself — in civil society — there are moral forces and authoritative voices that rise against terrorism and violent extremism, and we must identify those voices. Besides having leaders and credible and authoritative voices, it is important to integrate the groups and communities that undertstand the problems and wish to contribute their proposals: young people, women, students and civil society organizations. Governments should not only consult each other, but also provide to social agents that promote peace and understanding with the support and platforms they need.

  • Country

    Indonesia
  • Extracts

    Secondly, deradicalization programmes must be complemented by counter-radicalization, which aims at providing the public with narratives to counter those of the terrorists. Our counter-radicalization programmes involve many important stakeholders, such as educational and religious institutions, youth organizations, media, women, victims of terrorist attacks and even former terrorists, at both the national and provincial levels. Within the context of counterradicalization, we have put in place appropriate measures to prevent the spread of terrorists’ messages through the Internet. We also use the Internet to prevent, detect and deter acts of terrorism. That include creating websites to disseminate messages of peace and respect and the gathering of information that may lead to the prevention of terrorism and prosecution of terrorist suspects.

  • Country

    Norway
  • Extracts

    Governments have the primary responsibility for preventing extremism, but they can only succeed if  they work closely with civil society, including with young people and women. That is why Norway has initiated the launch of two civil-society networks. First, there is YouthCAN, which is a network of young people working together against violent extremism, not least by developing alternative narratives. Secondly, we have established an alliance of women’s organizations. Many of the women in the alliance have suffered directly from extremism in places like Syria and Iraq. There can be no more qualified and credible voices in speaking out against terrorism than its victims and witnesses. Norway will continue to work with these networks and help them expand.

  • Country

    Bangladesh
  • Extracts

    Fourthly, it will be crucial to give due consideration to the impact of terrorist and violent extremist ideologies on women in affected communities. We must revisit the traditional approaches, in which women are seen as victims of terrorism and violent extremism, and further explore their potential roles as agents of prevention, resilience and change at the community level — and even as perpetrators.

  • Country

    Myanmar
  • Extracts

    The role of women is important in participating in the decision-making process on all political, economic and social platforms. Children and young people must be cared for and provided with educational opportunities throughout their lives, with a view to knowing

Peace Processes
  • Country

    Colombia
  • Extracts

    Women should be included in all stages of the design, implementation, monitoring and evaluation of counter-terrorism efforts. Those efforts must be accompanied by the promotion of education for girls and women, which in the medium- and long-term, enables them to increase their capabilities, knowledge and resources and which, by extension, will enable them to play a more active role in the actions that States and societies take in countering terrorism and violent extremism.

  • Country

    Norway
  • Extracts

    Governments have the primary responsibility for preventing extremism, but they can only succeed if  they work closely with civil society, including with young people and women. That is why Norway has initiated the launch of two civil-society networks. First, there is YouthCAN, which is a network of young people working together against violent extremism, not least by developing alternative narratives. Secondly, we have established an alliance of women’s organizations. Many of the women in the alliance have suffered directly from extremism in places like Syria and Iraq. There can be no more qualified and credible voices in speaking out against terrorism than its victims and witnesses. Norway will continue to work with these networks and help them expand.

Protection
  • Country

    Malaysia
  • Extracts

    Long before the Geneva Conventions existed, Prophet Muhammad and subsequent scholars instituted a just-war doctrine. Among other things, during the conduct of war, Muslims are forbidden from harming non-combatants, particularly women, children, the elderly and the sick, as well as envoys, diplomats and those praying in houses of worship. They are even prohibited from harming civilian objects, including water wells, trees, crops and livestock. 

  • Country

    Malaysia
  • Extracts

    On a final note, I wish to stress that terrorist attacks do not discriminate among women or children; they do not discriminate between old or young; black or white; Muslims, Jews or Christians; rich or poor. All of us are potential victims of terrorism. In our response to this threat, let us not allow the terrorists to divide us. Hysterical responses to terrorism, including by discriminating against a group of people for their peaceful religious beliefs or branding an entire group of people as terrorists, will merely perpetuate terror and paranoia and further serve the terrorists’ narrative.

  • Country

    Netherlands
  • Extracts

    The dozens of ordinary men, women and children in a park in Lahore killed by a suicide bomber targeting Christians at Easter; the dozens of lives lost in terrorist strikes at Brussels’ airport and metro, and today, the tragic attacks in Baghdad killing at least 85 people underline the urgency of this debate.

  • Country

    Colombia
  • Extracts

    Women should be included in all stages of the design, implementation, monitoring and evaluation of counter-terrorism efforts. Those efforts must be accompanied by the promotion of education for girls and women, which in the medium- and long-term, enables them to increase their capabilities, knowledge and resources and which, by extension, will enable them to play a more active role in the actions that States and societies take in countering terrorism and violent extremism.

  • Country

    Indonesia
  • Extracts

    Secondly, deradicalization programmes must be complemented by counter-radicalization, which aims at providing the public with narratives to counter those of the terrorists. Our counter-radicalization programmes involve many important stakeholders, such as educational and religious institutions, youth organizations, media, women, victims of terrorist attacks and even former terrorists, at both the national and provincial levels. Within the context of counterradicalization, we have put in place appropriate measures to prevent the spread of terrorists’ messages through the Internet. We also use the Internet to prevent, detect and deter acts of terrorism. That include creating websites to disseminate messages of peace and respect and the gathering of information that may lead to the prevention of terrorism and prosecution of terrorist suspects.

  • Country

    Afghanistan
  • Extracts

    In the current global climate of unspeakable brutality committed by these terrorist outfits, let us not forget that it was the Taliban who stoned women to death; it was the Taliban who closed girls’ schools, thereby denying millions of girls of their right to education; it was the Taliban who prevented women from pursuing a livelihood; and it was they who introduced suicide attacks on civilians and destroyed towns and villages in Afghanistan. One can easily trace how the Taliban long started promoting Al-Qaida and Da’esh-style divisive and hateful ideology.

  • Country

    Palestine
  • Extracts

     Moreover, it is imperative to undertake efforts to foster an honest, open intercivilization and interreligious dialogue that involves and reaches not only leaders and Governments, but also the average civilian, including young people and women.

  • Country

    Myanmar
  • Extracts

     On the extremist front, terrorism preys on vulnerable groups, such as women and children, and even soft targets such as medical facilities and health-care personnel. Terrorism ignores geographical and ethical boundaries. 

Displacement and Humanitarian Response
  • Country

    Afghanistan
  • Extracts

    In the current global climate of unspeakable brutality committed by these terrorist outfits, let us not forget that it was the Taliban who stoned women to death; it was the Taliban who closed girls’ schools, thereby denying millions of girls of their right to education; it was the Taliban who prevented women from pursuing a livelihood; and it was they who introduced suicide attacks on civilians and destroyed towns and villages in Afghanistan. One can easily trace how the Taliban long started promoting Al-Qaida and Da’esh-style divisive and hateful ideology.

Human Rights
  • Country

    Malaysia
  • Extracts

    On a final note, I wish to stress that terrorist attacks do not discriminate among women or children; they do not discriminate between old or young; black or white; Muslims, Jews or Christians; rich or poor. All of us are potential victims of terrorism. In our response to this threat, let us not allow the terrorists to divide us. Hysterical responses to terrorism, including by discriminating against a group of people for their peaceful religious beliefs or branding an entire group of people as terrorists, will merely perpetuate terror and paranoia and further serve the terrorists’ narrative.

  • Country

    Spain
  • Extracts

    As occurred on Sunday with Cairo, Today we woke up to the news of new attacks in Baghdad, which have caused more than 70 fatalities. Most of the victims were women who were going to do their daily shopping. Once again, the daily lives of citizens have been tragically cut short. I offer my most heartfelt condolences to the people and the authorities of Iraq, and its Ambassador here present.

  • Country

    Ukraine
  • Extracts

    Only by combining more nuanced and comprehensive countering and prevention measures that address governance deficit, promote social development and dialogue and respect for the rule of law and human rights, develop strategic communications, engage women and youth and expand public-private partnerships can we reduce the appeal of and support for terrorist groups and enhance resilience against them. 

  • Country

    Norway
  • Extracts

    Governments have the primary responsibility for preventing extremism, but they can only succeed if  they work closely with civil society, including with young people and women. That is why Norway has initiated the launch of two civil-society networks. First, there is YouthCAN, which is a network of young people working together against violent extremism, not least by developing alternative narratives. Secondly, we have established an alliance of women’s organizations. Many of the women in the alliance have suffered directly from extremism in places like Syria and Iraq. There can be no more qualified and credible voices in speaking out against terrorism than its victims and witnesses. Norway will continue to work with these networks and help them expand.

Justice, Rule of Law and Security Sector Reform
  • Country

    Malaysia
  • Extracts

    On a final note, I wish to stress that terrorist attacks do not discriminate among women or children; they do not discriminate between old or young; black or white; Muslims, Jews or Christians; rich or poor. All of us are potential victims of terrorism. In our response to this threat, let us not allow the terrorists to divide us. Hysterical responses to terrorism, including by discriminating against a group of people for their peaceful religious beliefs or branding an entire group of people as terrorists, will merely perpetuate terror and paranoia and further serve the terrorists’ narrative.

  • Country

    Ukraine
  • Extracts

    Only by combining more nuanced and comprehensive countering and prevention measures that address governance deficit, promote social development and dialogue and respect for the rule of law and human rights, develop strategic communications, engage women and youth and expand public-private partnerships can we reduce the appeal of and support for terrorist groups and enhance resilience against them. 

  • Country

    Bangladesh
  • Extracts

    Fourthly, it will be crucial to give due consideration to the impact of terrorist and violent extremist ideologies on women in affected communities. We must revisit the traditional approaches, in which women are seen as victims of terrorism and violent extremism, and further explore their potential roles as agents of prevention, resilience and change at the community level — and even as perpetrators.

  • Country

    Myanmar
  • Extracts

     On the extremist front, terrorism preys on vulnerable groups, such as women and children, and even soft targets such as medical facilities and health-care personnel. Terrorism ignores geographical and ethical boundaries.